A number of former and retired judge advocates (JAGs) established the Former JAGs Working Group in February 2025 following the Secretary of Defense’s unprecedented removal of the Army, Navy, and Air Force Judge Advocates General. Originally formed to alert all Americans about that event’s broader adverse impact on the role and rule of law in the military and to counter its effective dismantling of established legal guardrails within the Department of Defense, today our coalition of former military judge advocates is dedicated to serving as an independent, public-service resource grounded in the laws governing the use of the U.S. Armed Forces. Members served on active duty and in the reserve components of the Army, Navy, Air Force, Marines, and Coast Guard, as well as in civilian attorney and leadership positions in the Department of Defense.
The materials presented on this site reflect and incorporate the legal and ethical standards, reasoning, and methodologies JAGs traditionally use when advising commanders on the legality of military actions. Although all factual assumptions rely exclusively on public information, the legal principles articulated in each document, interview, and essay are the same ones that guide real-world operational decision-making.
By publishing these briefs, the Former JAGs Working Group hopes to help policymakers, journalists, and the public evaluate whether current and future uses of the U.S. military are rooted in objective analysis, good-faith arguments, and solid legal principles. Where such rigorous review is absent, these materials are also intended to help identify and measure the likely risks to civilian control of the military, adherence to the rule of law, and the integrity of national security decision-making.
Documents and Essays (Newest → Oldest)
Legal Foundations of Honorable Military Service
STATEMENT OF THE FORMER JAGS WORKING GROUP ON INTERNATIONAL LEGAL OBLIGATIONS TOWARD DOWNED AIRMEN
STATEMENT OF THE FORMER JAGS WORKING GROUP ON THE WARRIOR ACT AND WOMEN IN THE MILITARY
FOURTH MEMORANDUM TO MEMBERS OF CONGRESS AND STAFF
Statement on the United States’ “Covert” Attack on Venezuela
Statement on UCMJ Investigation of Senator Mark Kelly
Third Memorandum to Congress: Anticipated Military Uses and Legal Risks
Second Memorandum to Congress: Detailing JAGs as Immigration Judges
First Memorandum to Congress: Guardrails on Employment of Military Judge Advocates
Proposal: Judge Advocate General Independence Act of 2025
Statement on the Importance of the JAG Corps
Member Essays, Articles, and Opinions
Hypothetical Legal Advice to SecDef Hegseth on “No Quarter” Statement (from Office of General Counsel)
Military Law on “Contemptuous Words” Should be Reformed
Hypothetical Legal Review of Use of the U.S. Military in Greenland
News Coverage
Trump’s genocidal threat to Iran may have caused irreparable damage — to the U.S.Trump’s threats diminished U.S. legitimacy and furnished our enemies with recruiting material.


Vance: US fundamentally completed military objectives in Iran


VIEWPOINTS: Trump’s Insurance Policy? People should start thinking seriously about what might happen between now and January 20, 2029.


When War Crimes Rhetoric Becomes Battlefield Reality: The Slippery Slope to Total War on Iran
Army helicopters greeting Kid Rock was a scandal. So was Pete Hegseth’s response. The Defense secretary’s disdain with rules is coupled with his overt efforts to politicize the U.S. military to align


Cuba Libre: One Man’s Morality or Our Law?
When the secretary of defense plays preacher


Congress Must Define ‘Unlawful Order’ Under Military Law


Opinion | Why Pete Hegseth can't reduce Mark Kelly's rank and pay


Former military lawyer calls U.S. boat strikes ‘murder’


Ex-JAG Officer: Hegseth not being in room for strikes is hard to believe


Experts accuse Trump admin of leaving top admiral 'exposed' to legal consequences: report


U.S. Boat Strike Campaign: Questions Congress Should Ask


"Kill All Crew Members": Margaret Donovan on Hegseth's Alleged Lethal Boat Strike Order


Retired US Army JAG officer says Trump admin committed 'murder'


Retired Ma. Gen. Steven Lepper on Military Strikes on Alleged Drug Boats


What happens inside a command center during a military strike?


Hegseth's Deadly Fiasco: Eugene Fidell Explains


Professional Responsibility and the Boat Strikes


War Crime...or Murder?

