top of page
All Posts


Accountability Will Come – What Should It Look Like for the Department of Defense?
By Frank Kendall Originally published by Just Security: Here In the foreseeable future, the Trump administration will come to an end. At that time, a new president and a new secretary of defense will have to confront the question of what to do about the many abuses of power and almost certain violations of both domestic and international law and of regulations committed within the Department of Defense during Trump’s second term. While in some ways this is still a distant pro
Former JAG Working Group
5 days ago8 min read
‘Trust us’ is no excuse for the Pentagon’s deadly boat strikes
Written by Steven Lepper and Eugene Fidell Originally published by Boston Globe: Here Steven J. Lepper is a retired major general in the US Air Force, where he served as deputy judge advocate general of the Air Force. Eugene R. Fidell served as a judge advocate in the US Coast Guard and is a visiting lecturer at Yale Law School. On Oct. 4, the US military announced that it sank another alleged narcotrafficking boat in the Caribbean Sea and killed its four occupants. The death
Former JAG Working Group
Oct 134 min read


Plan B for Trump’s election intimidation: An iron fist in a velvet glove
Originally published in The Hill: Here Written by: Steven Lepper, Dan Maurer, and Eugene Fidell Gen. Dan Caine, the nation’s senior-most military leader, recently told Sen Elissa Slotkin (D-Mich.) that the U.S. military has “no plans” to be at polling places in November. But President Trump has made it impossible to dismiss fears of military interference. To the contrary, his persistent assault on the integrity of the voting process, his suggestion that Republicans “should ta
Former JAG Working Group
Oct 123 min read
The National Guard and elections: Legal authorities and guidance for judge advocates
Originally published by Protect Democracy. Here For the full PDF of the report see here Domestic military missions during election season raise unique issues that require careful examination. Given the National Guard’s domestic presence, National Guard judge advocates and command staff must know the laws and regulations that ensure the administration of free and fair elections is never undermined, even inadvertently, by those sworn to defend the Constitution. Retired state Ad
Former JAG Working Group
Sep 212 min read
SEVENTH MEMORANDUM TO MEMBERS OF CONGRESS AND STAFF
SUBJECT: Escaping the Quagmire: The Challenges Facing Active Duty General and Flag Officers of the US Armed Forces In early 2025, the Secretary of Defense fired the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Chief of Naval Operations, Vice Chief of Staff of the Air Force, and the Army and Air Force’s top uniformed lawyers. In doing so, he suggested that the four-star leaders were products of diversity policies rather than merit and that the lawyers would be “roadblocks” to the
Former JAG Working Group
Sep 15 min read
The Rule of Law in the U.S. Armed Forces: A Six-Month Assessment from the Former JAGs Working Group
August 28, 2026 Today, the Iran War completes its sixth month. Before it began, a number of the actions taken by the Department of Defense and the armed forces since the start of President Trump’s second term had raised significant Rule of Law issues. The list has only grown since the administration started this illegal war. The national security implications also mount as we continue to deplete our arsenal, alienate our allies, inflict serious damage on our economy, and
Former JAG Working Group
Aug 287 min read
“Can We Do This?”: The Role of Military Leaders and Their Legal Advice
By Dan Maurer Originally published in Just Security: Here In recent remarks to graduates at the National Defense University, the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, General Dan Caine drew a sharp distinction between two categories of advice in military operations: “can we do this?” versus “should we do this?” He stated that the first category is appropriate for military leaders to address, but that the second is verboten, suggesting it would be a breach of professional nor
Former JAG Working Group
Aug 2515 min read
Pete Hegseth wants to turn Stars and Stripes into a Pentagon mouthpiece
Originally published on MSNOW Here Written by Rachel VanLandingham Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth recently engaged in another one of his personnel purges in an attempt to transform the military into one that thinks like him. Having already fired senior military commanders and top military lawyers, Hegseth has now forced out, for “insubordination,” the top two civilians who run the storied military newspaper Stars and Stripes, according to outgoing editor-in-chief Erik Slavin.
Former JAG Working Group
Aug 253 min read
The military’s request for ‘creative’ ideas in Iran is an admission of failure
By Rachel VanLandignham Origially Published by MSNOW Here In what we might wish was satire from the likes of The Onion, CNN reported Sunday that U.S. Central Command (the command running the war with Iran) sent an email last week to military analystsunabashedly proclaiming that top military leaders “are looking for new creative and unconventional ways to pressure and punish Iran.” CNN cited a source familiar with the message when describing the email’s content and a second so
Former JAG Working Group
Aug 44 min read
Statement on President Trump’s Threat to Bomb Bridges and Power Plants in Iran
"Regardless of legality, the U.S. targeting Iranian infrastructure used by civilians is likely to cause far more civilian deaths than those caused by targeting purely military objects. In addition, under the laws of war, targeting civilian infrastructure is only lawful after a case-by-case determination is made that such an object makes an effective contribution to military action and that its destruction offers a military advantage. Publicly threatening automatic strikes aga
Former JAG Working Group
Jul 231 min read
The U.S. military’s escalating strikes in Iran may be legal. That doesn’t make them justified.
By Rachel VanLandingham Originally Published July 21, 2026 by MSNOW Here In its recent strikes in Iran, the United States widened its targeting aperture to bomb sites directly serving the Iranian population, such as electrical power plants, bridges, railway stations and roads. By doing so, the U.S. deliberately chose to inflict greater suffering on Iranian civilians. Over 500 Iranians have reportedly been injured this month, and more than 50 people, including children, have b
Former JAG Working Group
Jul 204 min read


How to Choose Which Military Members to Hold Accountable for Illegal Boat Strikes
The military’s “Requirement for Exemplary Conduct” statute enables fair prosecutorial discretion By Dan Maurer Originally Published by Just Security Here Not long after beginning his second term in office, President Donald Trump addressed leaders in the Department of Justice: “So now as the chief law enforcement officer in our country, I will insist upon and demand full and complete accountability for the wrongs and abuses that have occurred.” He was, of course, referring to
Former JAG Working Group
Jul 1515 min read
OpinionThanks to Pete Hegseth, some U.S. service members lost full freedom of religion
By Rachel VanLandingham Originally published by MSNOW on June 10, 2026 Here There’s an old saying: There are no atheists in foxholes. Faith plays a large role in the lives of many service members (including, yes, uniformed atheists). The U.S. military has long provided religious support to service members who are naturally often far from home and their faith communities. Given that the First Amendment prohibits the government both from establishing a religion and from prevent
Former JAG Working Group
Jun 94 min read
Thoughts for Judge Advocates in Challenging Times
Originally Published in Just Security Here By Calvin Lederer, John Ewers, Eugene Fidell, and Steven Lepper The Former JAGs Working Group Please Note that the full PDF includes footnotes please view that version for full context. The Former JAGs Working Group is comprised of several dozen former judge advocates from all the Armed Services and components ranging from junior officers to admirals and generals. Perceiving that the Nation’s senior military officers are increasin
Former JAG Working Group
Jun 87 min read
Rules of Engagement When the Troops Appear at Polling Sites
By Dan Maurer Originally published in Lawfare: Here Open, noncoercive, and safe elections are a hallmark of a healthy democracy. Today, those characteristics are in jeopardy. In January, President Trump boasted of his administration’s first year back in office and said, “When you think of it, we shouldn’t even have an election.” Speaking on former Deputy FBI Director Dan Bongino’s podcast in early February, Trump claimed that illegal immigrants “were brought to our country to
Former JAG Working Group
Jun 313 min read
The Pentagon can honor our military dead this Memorial Day by committing to fight the right way
By Rachel VanLandingham Originally Published by MSNOW on May 25, 2026 Here On this Memorial Day, we should take stock that the U.S. military remains one of the most respected public institutions in America. And for good reason. Our military has strived mightily since its Vietnam War nadir to foster professionalism grounded on honor and implemented programs to help ensure that the American way of fighting comports with the law of war and American values to the greatest extent
Former JAG Working Group
May 244 min read


The Armed Forces Need the Military Justice Review Panel
By Franklin Rosenblatt and Eugene Fidell Published May 19, 2026 in Just Security Here As U.S. secretary of defense, Pete Hegseth is trying to overhaul how legal advice is provided in the Pentagon and how the broader military justice system operates. Although he’s referred to the Judge Advocate General Corps as “vital,” he has also called military lawyers “JAGoffs.” That contempt appears to be shaping many of his decisions. Soon after taking office, he fired the top lawyers fo
Former JAG Working Group
May 185 min read
Pete Hegseth thinks the lawmakers who know the most about the military should have the least to say
By Rachel VanLandingham Originally Published May 17, 2026 by MSNOW Here It is ironic as well as troubling that Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth recently went on X to accuse Sen. Mark Kelly, D-Ariz., a decorated naval aviator who flew combat missions and served as a NASA astronaut, of improperly sharing privileged military information on CBS’ “Face the Nation” on Sunday. It’s ironic because Hegseth himself revealed classified information and compromised operational security last
Former JAG Working Group
May 163 min read
Legal Foundations of Honorable Military Service
Originally Published by Just Security Here Please Note that the full PDF includes footnotes please view that version for full context. Legal Foundations of Honorable Military Service The Former JAGs Working Group Perspective By Daniel Maurer, Steven J. Lepper and Eugene R. Fidell Since September, the United States has engaged in an invasion of Venezuela and initiated an armed conflict against Iran. In January, the Trump administration threatened to annex Greenland – an unprec
Former JAG Working Group
Apr 3012 min read
SIXTH MEMORANDUM TO MEMBERS OF CONGRESS AND STAFF
21 April 2026 FROM: The Former Judge Advocates Working Group SUBJECT: The Insurrection Act and Military Personnel at Polling Places In our Third Memorandum dated 7 October 2025, the Former JAGs Working Group alerted Congress to two potential threats to our democracy involving the (mis)use of our military: (1) the targeting of Americans under the pretense that they are members of “domestic terror organizations” such as “Antifa,” and (2) the intimidation of voters by posting tr
Former JAG Working Group
Apr 209 min read
bottom of page